Great write up! Living so close, I kick myself for not getting down there more than a couple times a year. Note: If you haven't played MidPines, PineNeedles, SouthernPines, you might want to get them on the schedule soon. The hotels at PineNeedles and MidPines just got acquired by Marine & Lawn, so expect prices to go way up starting in 2026 (renovations start in Fall 2025) https://businessnc.com/mid-pines-pine-needles-enter-joint-venture-with-marine-and-lawn-hotels/

I think these days the remote destinations in northern Scotland are most attractive to me. Places like the Machrie, Durness, Iona, Whalsay. The journey there is the fun part with so many of the courses there.

The few historical photos I've seen of SP suggest that the course did have a rugged, sandy look, as well as big features to match the scale of the land. The natural ground was probably scrubbier than it is now (i.e., less straight-up exposed sand), but again, we have to let Franz's work mature. But overall I think SP was a tricky restoration job because the course had sand greens until at least the mid-30s, and it's unclear whether Ross ever really designed "Ross greens" there.

I guess the question that remains is was SP flashier than MP back in the time they were restoring to - indeed both a great trip

I think it's undeniable that Franz went bolder at Southern Pines than he did at Mid Pines. SP has far more bunker acreage than MP (and more waste-area acreage, too, probably?), and its greens a bigger and more busily contoured. Over time, though, as the new features settle in and mature, I'd bet that SP will become more similar to MP and Pine Needles, at least visually. Giving SP a bit more flash was likely an intentional choice, and a valid one. Each of the three courses now offers something unique. I prefer the elegance of MP, but many will prefer the boldness of SP.

Growing up in Ireland and have played most of big courses over my years. I've recently ventured to Scotland for golf trips and can't wait for the next one. There's so much depth there's not much commuting between courses if you stick to a particular area. Have done Fife, Aberdeen and my favorite East Lothian this June. Next on my wishlist is the Highlands and the west coast. Golf in Scotland feels like a pilgrimage can't stop thinking about playing Kilspindie, Musselburgh old and North Berwick. Like going back in time. Of course Ireland has great courses and we are definitely nicer people 😉 but Scotland has something that's good for the golf soul.

And might have the platonic ideal turn hut and 19th hole porch overlooking the 18th. Great way to spend a day.

One question I have is it seems the Franz restoration at Southern Pines is treated as some as way more over the top and critiqued than the one he did at Mid Pines. While I love SP and MP but having only seen both after the restorations, what might explain the different reactions to the work done? Does this say more about each course or about Franz's work?

Great write ups Will. Really enjoyed reading each one. Seems like you had a good experience so much underrated great golf in the area. Look forward to more articles like this in the future.

A great review and one of my absolute favorite spots. I could play there everyday.